The new Wranglers are nice, but pricey, and they hold their value as well (if not better) than a Tacoma or a diesel.
Looked at them at the local dealerships but you weren't going home with anything they had for under 33k new, and used isn't really much cheaper around here. Very popular, but more than I could spend. I didn't like the idea of financing one for 7 years so I could "afford" the payment.
You can still get them with manuals or auto and I hear the new 3.6L V6 is a good engine. I still think they are cool if you have the means, I just don't.
The craigslist crowd still wants ridiculous money for these things even when old and beat to s___.